Good—simple choices for a better life

Article illustration

Lovely Lyttelton ... or more coal?

Home » Blog » Annabel McAleer » Lovely Lyttelton ... or more coal?

Environment Canterbury is taking submissions on proposals to double coal exports from the Port of Lyttelton this week. Here's how to have your say.

The Port of Lyttelton is seeking resource consent to almost double its coal capacity to nearly five million tonnes each year, to handle growing exports from Solid Energy and Pike River Coal. Five million tonnes of coal would create over 10 billion tonnes of CO2-equivalent.

Lyttelton Harbour

Lyttelton Harbour

Metiria Turei, co-leader of the Green Party, writes:

"We all understand how burning coal affects climate change. Whether coal gets burned here or in China, we'll all suffer the consequences. The Port plans to expand a quarry, tear down a hill, dredge a bit of harbour and 'reclaim' another part. The environmental impact will be massive. Lyttelton Port shareholders stand to make a short-term profit but our children will be picking up the long-term costs. We think there's a different and better way towards prosperity for all New Zealanders.

"Environment Canterbury is taking submissions on the coal expansion proposal right now. Please take a few moments to tell Environment Canterbury that you oppose any expansion of the Lyttelton Port coal facility."

What you can do

Comments

Annabel McAleer
 
Wed February 10, 2010 @ 05:58 PM
I made my submission. It took 20 minutes, as I wanted to rephrase the Green Party points into my own words. And because it's fun to make long bits of writing shorter. Here's what I wrote:


1. Timing of Application


The timing of public notification of the application for the above consents occurred over the holiday period, meaning that affected individuals and groups have had little time to make submissions.



2. Insufficient Rationale


Increased extraction and export of coal is an insufficient rationale for the expansion of the port. Any economic benefit derived from increased coal extraction and export cannot outweigh the impact of coal combustion in terms of exacerbation of climate change. Increasing exports of coal is contradictory to the Government’s policy of New Zealand “doing its fair share” to combat climate change. Climate change and its consequences will impose economic costs that exceed the short-term economic gains to be obtained. 



3. Air quality


A greater volume of coal being stored at the port is likely to bring a greater volume of coal dust drift from the stockyard and dispersal over Lyttelton town. This carries a health risk, particularly for small children.



4. Use of high quality potable water


Water is a valuable public resource that is under pressure in Canterbury. Increased use of high quality potable water for damping down coal dust is not workable. With priority given to town use, when water supply is insufficient there will likely be periods when coal could not be sprayed adequately to mitigate dust.



5. Land reclamation


I oppose the privatisation of 10 ha of sea bed.



6. Landscape, Visual Amenity


The is likely to be significant negative visual impact created by the enlarged coal stockpile. 



7. Water quality


The cumulative effects of coal particulates and heavy metals on water quality and marine life are unknown and likely to be negative.



8. Economic considerations


The claimed economic benefits do not outweigh the negative contribution to climate change. The economic gains will accrue predominantly to the LPC and Solid Energy while the burden of the negative environmental impacts will predominantly be borne by the local residents. 



Decision Comment:

I wish the consent authority to decline all 12 applications. The purpose of the expansion, to increase coal exports, is environmentally irresponsible and has no long-term economic benefit. The expansion will have serious negative local impacts such as air and water pollution, and increased water stress for the region.
Last Edit: February 10, 2010 @ 06:02PM by Annabel McAleer 
Annabel McAleer
 
Mon April 19, 2010 @ 05:22 PM
Update: The consent application has been referred directly to the Environment Court, bypassing the council hearing process. This is allowed by recent changes to the RMA.
Brian
 
Wed April 21, 2010 @ 10:41 PM
I find the opposition to the coal exports a nonsense.
The coal to be exported is hard coking coal, it goes to steel making plants and is necessary for the steel making process to occur.
Steel is used for such items as windmills producing renewable energy, wave generators, public transport train and bus bodies, which are all supposed to be "green".

So why the objections?  Admit it, you just don't like coal, even though it's an absolute essential in this world.  Andif NZ doesn't provide it, someone else will.

Your arguments just don't stack up.

Add your comment

Anonymous comments are queued before publishing and it may take some time before they appear. Please consider creating an account and your comment will appear automatically. If you already have an account, please log in.








If you have trouble reading the code, click on the code itself to generate a new random code
 

More Goodness

The Good blog
  • Winter pick-me-ups
    article illustration

    As gloomy weather sets in, it's the little things that lift your mood. Like these candy-coloured retro leather purses from Green With Envy – a splash of gorgeousness on the daily shop. And we've got two to give away!

  • How to get rid of oxalis?
    article illustration

    Good's new gardening expert Zoe Carafice is ready and waiting to solve your dilemmas! Each question published on Zoe's blog or in Good receives a fab prize from Tui Garden. This week: how to eradicate oxalis bulbs.

  • One good reason to skip lunch
    article illustration

    Plenty of food that’s good enough to eat (but not good enough to sell) is disposed of every day. Kaibosh Food Rescue is aiming to change all that by collecting extra food and distributing it to charities. Now they're calling on Kiwis to donate the cost of a meal on Miss a Meal in May Day – so they can expand their mission to help out the hungry.

Good magazine
  • Urban harvest
    article illustration

    Could you live off the land? Nancy Howie travels to Canada to discover how one grassroots movement is redefining the suburban dream.

  • Where has fracking been allowed on the East Coast?
    article illustration

    Armed with exploration licenses issued by the New Zealand government, Tag Oil and its partner Apache intend to extract oil and gas from the East Coast. See the map here >

  • Man-made earthquakes
    article illustration

    Is it possible for human activity to cause quakes? One investigation in Blackpool, England discovered that more than fifty tremors in the region were caused by fracking operations. Read the article >

article illustration

Latest issue

Discover what gives your home soul, tips for easy entertaining and making favourite clothes last longer. Find latest research on honey for health and the brainiest breakfasts, plus guides to greenwashing, distilling and the best loo paper to buy.

Follow us

Latest comments

  • Kama Scarf on Winter pick-me-ups:
    Open the doors and windows when the sun is shinning during winter to let some fresh air through the house.  Yummy scented candles also  
  • Carola Corkill on Win a Showerdome:
    On a cleaning spree, I looked up and realised that the damp in the bathroom is wrecking the ceiling paint and wood trim. Opening the window  
  • keong on Soy vs cow milk:
    Hi Everyone, Just a question where d you get organic soy beans in auckland? If any one knows a spot can you please tell me. Thanks
  • B on Winter pick-me-ups:
    I often despise coming home after work to have to stand in the kitchen for ages cooking.  So I try to make huge pots or add extra vege'  
  • Erin on Winter pick-me-ups:
    For me, I make sure I know where my fuzzy tramping socks are - super for wearing in my beautiful work boots, and in my gumboots while I mow  
  • Hilary on Winter pick-me-ups:
    winterproof your home by reducing humidity inside (when it's damp it feels colder). It is amazing what a difference it makes to slick/squeeg  
  • leah c on Winter pick-me-ups:
    Soups, and lots of it.  Everyone likes it, it's warm hearty food and a great way of using up old veggies and some of the winter crops i  
  • Linda on Winter pick-me-ups:
    I make sure I have a bottle of one of the blackcurrant type syrups, I find it hard to keep up the water intake when the temps drop, so add h  

Blogs

Good pages

Good Shopping Handbook