Good—simple choices for a better life

Article illustration

Don't do crappy chocolate!

Home » Blog » Sarah Heeringa » Don't do crappy chocolate!

A cooking oil that is driving the destruction of the rainforests, displacing native people and threatening the survival of the orangutan is present in Cadbury's new chocolate recipe. So say the choco-lovers at Choco lovers Unite

Front image: Stu Spivack

Palm oil—blamed for a tree-felling rampage in Southeast Asia—is present or suspected in chocolates, soap products and margarines. Apparently it's also present in margarine brand Flora, KitKat and Cadbury Dairy Milk chocolate, as well as Dove soap, Comfort fabric conditioner and Persil washing powder.

The United Nations Environment Programme believes palm oil is the major driver of deforestation in Borneo and Sumatra. Hundreds of thousands of hectares of forest are cleared to make way for plantations from which 90 per cent of wildlife disappear, including the orangutan, which is fighting a losing battle against extinction. Orangutan numbers have dwindled by 90 percent since 1900, with the rate of loss accelerating in recent decades. Cadbury insists that their Palm Oil is sustainable. Do not be fooled. Cadbury is a paid-up member of the Roundtable on Sustainable Palm Oil, but this means nothing, say the critics. The Roundtable itself admits that it is only able to certify 4 percent of palm oil production as sustainable. About 85 per cent of the global supply comes from Borneo and Sumatra, where corruption is rife and where incursions into the forests are enforced by gun-toting security guards. If present rates of logging continue, the UN Environment Programme estimates that 98 per cent of forests in Indonesia may be destroyed by 2020.

It is believed that Cadbury now use the oil to bind and bulk out chocolate as a cheaper partial substitute for cocoa butter.

Criticisms from outraged consumers:

  • a 20 percent downsize from 250g to 200g
  • a 5 percent drop in cocoa solids from 26% to 21%
  • the inclusion of nasty vegetable fat as a filler
  • a downgrade of everything but the price
What you can do
Update

Cadbury Dairy Milk has gone fair trade!

 

Comments

PM
 
Mon July 06, 2009 @ 08:40 PM
wow, lots of grand claims, but no sources listed.
PM
 
Mon July 06, 2009 @ 09:31 PM
try these links for more information...
http://www.btimes.com.my/Current_News/BTIMES/articles/20090527195851/Article/
'Green' palm planters struggle to find buyers

and RSPO does not carry out audits of its members
source: http://www.facebook.com/topic.php?uid=96420193885&topic=10607
Last Edit: July 06, 2009 @ 09:34PM by Su Yin Khoo 
BN
 
Mon July 06, 2009 @ 10:08 PM
Oooh looky, the Cadbury PR machine is looking at your blog, Sarah... Pity the naysayers don't use their efforts for good not evil.
Carly Day
 
Tue July 07, 2009 @ 06:47 AM
Awesome blog. Thanks for making my petition available! I have been a passionate Orangutan Conservationist for a few years now and the more I learn the more outraged I become. The recent changes to cadbury were the icing on the cake. I have a facebook group with near 1,000 people, please join if you would like to add your voice, and sign the petition to Cadbury! I keep the facebook group updated with info on palm oil. Let's keep the momentum of this going. Thanks!
Last Edit: July 07, 2009 @ 09:16AM by Su Yin Khoo 
Fiona
 
Tue July 07, 2009 @ 10:21 PM
I received this email today from Whittakers.  Yay I can eat chocolate and be wildlife guilt free.  No Palm Oil :).

Thank you for your email.

Whittaker's chocolate does not contain palm oil and we will never use
palm oil in our products.

You may be interested to know that we are the only chocolate
manufactures in New Zealand that imports cocoa beans, roasts and refines
them in our factory in Porirua. We use Ghanaian cocoa beans because
they are amongst the best quality beans in the world and we only use
cocoa butter. By roasting our own cocoa beans we can control the whole
manufacturing process - "From Bean to Bar" and produce the premium taste
of Whittaker's chocolate.

Thank you for taking the time and trouble to contact us. We hope that
you continue to enjoy Whittaker's chocolate.

Kind regards

Philip Poole
Marketing Manager
Vincent Heeringa
 
Wed July 08, 2009 @ 07:40 AM
The whole things going viral with three Facebook groups, two Twitter accounts and this site, http://choclovers.org/
which I think was the original piece that led to the TV3 news item.

The bizarre thing is that Cadbury is missing in action, or at least in the social media sphere. Has anyone seen a Cadbury blog, Tweet or Facebook page? Or even an old fashioned letter?

Talk about meltdown.

Here are the links that Ive found so far:

ChocLovers
http://twitter.com/chocloversunite
http://choclovers.org/

Facebook - Carly Day
http://www.facebook.com/group.php?gid=99560141028
and

Facebook - Nath Brown's http://www.facebook.com/group.php?gid=96420193885

These links are off Nath Brown's Facebook page Sky News 2006 Orang-utans and Palm Oil Threat
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FsR_IpECSZ8

4 May 2009 - NZ Herald: http://www.nzherald.co.nz/world/news/article.cfm?c_id=2&objectid=10570214 

26 June 2009: Radio New Zealand - HAVE A LISTEN AND BE APPALLED WITH CADBURY'S ATTITUDE
Cadbury's new chocolate recipe gets thumbs down. Chocolate lovers, environmentalists and health specialists are condemning a recent change in the recipe for Cadbury's chocolate bars.http://www.radionz.co.nz/__data/assets/audio_item/0005/1988708/ckpt-20090626-1816-Cadburys_new_chocolate_recipe_gets_thumbs_down-m048.asx

1 July 2009: TV3 - Cadbury's new chocolate range raises eyebrows.http://www.3news.co.nz/Cadburys-new-chocolate-range-raises-eyebrows/tabid/420/articleID/110868/cat/52/Default.aspx

5 July 2009: Sign this online petition "Remove Palm Oil from Cadbury chocolate"http://www.thepetitionsite.com/1/Remove-palm-oil-from-cadbury

Wayne Attwell
www.boldhorizon.co.nz
 
Fri July 10, 2009 @ 08:50 AM
Check out this blog post.
http://www.boldhorizon.co.nz/brand-marketing-blog/index.php/wayne-attwell-blog/2009/07/08/whittakers-hammers-cadbury-in-comparativ
Last Edit: July 10, 2009 @ 09:53AM by Su Yin Khoo 
Marian Harford
 
Fri July 10, 2009 @ 04:26 PM

What a rip off.  I've always bought Cadburys and until today never knew that Persil contained Palm Oil as well.  Think Whittakers it will be from now on!

Julia Campbell
www.fairtrade.org.nz
 
Mon July 13, 2009 @ 10:44 AM
Scarborough Fair do a range of Fairtrade Organic chocolate which is made in NZ and contains no hidden nasties! 

I think it's great to see Kiwi's get passionate about this: why not petition other chocolatiers to source sustainable and ethical cocoa.  Buying products with the FAIRTRADE Mark guarantee you the consumer that the environment and the farmers are protected.  It's not only available for chocolate, but for tea, coffee, sugar and cotton and hopefully coming soon to beauty products too.
Gena Tuffery
 
Fri July 17, 2009 @ 01:38 PM
Yeah safest to go Fairtrade, for slavery and savoury reasons too. This is what turned me: Tell them, when they are eating chocolate, they are eating my flesh" - Vincent, an enslaved cocoa worker in the Ivory Coast.
Gina Eccersall-Panther
 
Tue August 04, 2009 @ 08:27 PM
Additionally - do some ethical fundraising... I discovered Trade Aid does chocolate. It makes a nice change from the tired old Cadbury foisted upon you by schools. An added benefit is you get those consumers who are tired of all the other fundraising ideas. 
http://www.tradeaid.org.nz/Get%20Involved/Fundraise%20with%20Trade%20Aid
for more info

Add your comment

Anonymous comments are queued before publishing and it may take some time before they appear. Please consider creating an account and your comment will appear automatically. If you already have an account, please log in.








If you have trouble reading the code, click on the code itself to generate a new random code
 

More Goodness

The Good blog
  • Winter pick-me-ups
    article illustration

    As gloomy weather sets in, it's the little things that lift your mood. Like these candy-coloured retro leather purses from Green With Envy – a splash of gorgeousness on the daily shop. And we've got two to give away!

  • How to get rid of oxalis?
    article illustration

    Good's new gardening expert Zoe Carafice is ready and waiting to solve your dilemmas! Each question published on Zoe's blog or in Good receives a fab prize from Tui Garden. This week: how to eradicate oxalis bulbs.

  • One good reason to skip lunch
    article illustration

    Plenty of food that’s good enough to eat (but not good enough to sell) is disposed of every day. Kaibosh Food Rescue is aiming to change all that by collecting extra food and distributing it to charities. Now they're calling on Kiwis to donate the cost of a meal on Miss a Meal in May Day – so they can expand their mission to help out the hungry.

Good magazine
  • Urban harvest
    article illustration

    Could you live off the land? Nancy Howie travels to Canada to discover how one grassroots movement is redefining the suburban dream.

  • Where has fracking been allowed on the East Coast?
    article illustration

    Armed with exploration licenses issued by the New Zealand government, Tag Oil and its partner Apache intend to extract oil and gas from the East Coast. See the map here >

  • Man-made earthquakes
    article illustration

    Is it possible for human activity to cause quakes? One investigation in Blackpool, England discovered that more than fifty tremors in the region were caused by fracking operations. Read the article >

article illustration

Latest issue

Discover what gives your home soul, tips for easy entertaining and making favourite clothes last longer. Find latest research on honey for health and the brainiest breakfasts, plus guides to greenwashing, distilling and the best loo paper to buy.

Follow us

Latest comments

  • B on Winter pick-me-ups:
    I often despise coming home after work to have to stand in the kitchen for ages cooking.  So I try to make huge pots or add extra vege'  
  • Erin on Winter pick-me-ups:
    For me, I make sure I know where my fuzzy tramping socks are - super for wearing in my beautiful work boots, and in my gumboots while I mow  
  • Hilary on Winter pick-me-ups:
    winterproof your home by reducing humidity inside (when it's damp it feels colder). It is amazing what a difference it makes to slick/squeeg  
  • leah c on Winter pick-me-ups:
    Soups, and lots of it.  Everyone likes it, it's warm hearty food and a great way of using up old veggies and some of the winter crops i  
  • Linda on Winter pick-me-ups:
    I make sure I have a bottle of one of the blackcurrant type syrups, I find it hard to keep up the water intake when the temps drop, so add h  
  • Cassidy on Your eco kitchen makeover:
    Although I love the idea of the glass jars for baking ingredients etc. would Tupperware be alright as it lasts a lifetime?
  • Karen on Winter pick-me-ups:
    I've just finished knitting a sweater for a hot water bottle cover, so it stays hot longer and also doesn't get to hot when hugging it. Trou  
  • Gaye on Winter pick-me-ups:
    Nothing beats coming home to  a spicy beef curry and a steamed jam sponge pudding smothered with custard after a brisk walk embracing t  

Blogs

Good pages

Good Shopping Handbook