Good—simple choices for a better life

Article illustration

What's really wrong with the economy?

Home » Magazine » Good, issue 4 » What's really wrong with the economy?

Damon Birchfield believes our current economic system is broken—and it's a much bigger issue than a few collapsing banks

It is time to question the validity of the assumption that human wellbeing and happiness are achievable only through consumption, more consumption and growth. The assumption may drive the policy agendas of most of the world’s governments, but the reality is our house of credit cards is crumbling—and so it should. Our current consumer-oriented economic system treats neither people nor the environment as if they really matter.

The current crisis in the world’s financial markets provides a perfect opportunity to re-think the relationship between economics, people and the environment.

It is time to sack the ‘growth is good’ mantra. Good for whom, exactly? The CEOs in the US, Europe and other G8 nations who earn an average 262 times more than their workers? Almost certainly. Good for our planet and the future of its six billion human inhabitants? Not likely.

Let’s examine the underpinning of the economic growth myth by looking at how it is measured. Growth can be defined as the increase in the volume of goods and services a nation produces. It occurs when ordinary people like you and I consume more, which in turn means that production levels increase to meet these new demands. This is how the growth cycle is formed.

The main measure of growth is Gross Domestic Product (GDP), which is worked out by totaling consumption, gross investment, and government spending (exports minus imports).

GDP is used as an indicator of a nation’s welfare. The inference is, the more we have consumed the happier we all are. But as far back as 1934 its inventor, Simon Kuznet, said: “The welfare of a nation [can] scarcely be inferred from a measure of national income.”

Simon Kuznet recognised that GDP was unable to take into account distinctions between quantity and quality of growth, between costs and returns, and between the short and long term, and so was actually of little value in measuring human welfare.

Repeated studies show that while our material wealth has significantly grown over the past few decades, our level of happiness has not significantly changed. Why? Simply because in reality wealth is not a big determinant of satisfaction or happiness—ask anybody who has won Lotto. Having good relationships with other people and the planet makes people happy, and a clear sense of purpose and meaning in our daily life. Money is secondary, although it still has an important role to play.

Common economic wisdom, however, sees that a country is only successful and prosperous when it achieves high levels of growth. It is failing and in recession when the level of growth dips significantly for more than two financial quarters—six months. That’s why we are all supposed to be really depressed right now.

The question is: does a decline in GDP mean the end of all the good things we enjoy? Perhaps for a while, if you’ve maxed out your credit card and have been living beyond your means. But from a planetary perspective, the very opposite is true. When growth is high, the planet’s ecosystem is taking a hammering at our expense.

Consider the following trends, a direct result of unprecedented growth in both human population and economic activities over the past 200 years:

  • 60 percent of our planet’s ozone has been lost in 60 years
  • 70 percent of the world’s forests have been eliminated
  • 90 percent of all large fish have disappeared from our oceans

These are serious issues, and there are many more. The United Nations Millennium Ecosystem Assessment concludes: “Human activity is putting such strain on the natural functions of the Earth that the ability of the planet’s ecosystem to sustain future generations can no longer be taken for granted.”

Global financial meltdown or not, this is no time to start equivocating on the critical importance to our world of global sustainability. Perhaps this current financial crisis provides us with a timely opportunity to examine some of the assumptions we have about our lives, and what really makes us happy.

If our happiness comes only at the expense of the planet, then we have a real and systemic problem. These are issues that we everyday citizens have a right to talk about—it’s not just the domain of economists.

People can demand an economic model that genuinely puts them and the environment first, and we will be happier for it. As former World Bank economist Hermann Daly, an advocate for the ‘steady state’ economic model, has said: “There is something fundamentally wrong with treating the Earth as if it is a business in liquidation.”

Add your comment

Anonymous comments are queued before publishing and it may take some time before they appear. Please consider creating an account and your comment will appear automatically. If you already have an account, please log in.








If you have trouble reading the code, click on the code itself to generate a new random code
 

More Goodness

The Good blog
  • Epic walking vol. 1
    article illustration

    Good guest bloggers The Ministry of Silly Walks are back after a 50km training walk, linking up some great tracks from Porirua to Wellington.

  • A touch of luxury
    article illustration

    We think this might be the ultimate glamping accessory – Tamsin Cooper's luxurious velvet and silk overnight bag. And we've got one to give away!

  • There's still time to nominate and win!
    article illustration

    Sick and tired of having to use scissors to open your razor packet? Hate filling up your bin with all the plastic left over from wrapped veggies? Here’s a chance to have your say on some of the best and worst packaging on New Zealand’s shelves.

Good magazine
  • Beginner’s guide to foraging
    article illustration

    Food's all around us – we just need to learn how to see it, explains the UK foraging queen Alys Fowler. Read on to learn more about finding food in unusual places

  • Food Bill: what’s the fuss?

    There’s grumbling over garden fences
    about a new bill before Parliament.
    Andy Kenworthy takes a closer look

  • Good guide: Pork
    article illustration

    Buying pork raises lots of eco and ethical questions – which is not something you want to grapple
    with when you’re just after a ham sandwich.
    Andy Kenworthy surveys the options

article illustration

Latest issue

We cultivate the art of slow and bust five common food allergy myths. There are delicious fruity desserts and old-fashioned drinks to make, easy gardening tips, an inspirational glamping guide and the latest on natural body scrubs. Plus we look at the tough topic of slavery in our seas.

Follow us

Latest comments

  • Chardonnay on A touch of luxury:
     Three years this month ago i gave my BFF one of these gorgeous bags from Tamsin for her 40th birthday and we took it on its  
  • Helen on A touch of luxury:
    I travel light ,silk pj's ,plus silk gown ,one change of under and outer wear and 20 mls of luxury body wash and shampoo, but my most specia  
  • Sharon on A touch of luxury:
    Cocktail shaker and glasses and salmon tweezers ; I NEVER travel without them
  • Angela on A touch of luxury:
    I'm not one to take a whole bunch of stuff like girly hair straighteners, heels, make up, fancy clothes and accessories etc camping. I must  
  • sandra on A touch of luxury:
    Glamping to me is a necessity not a luxury .. there is nothing like knowing that you will be comfortable, warm and well-fed and watered with  
  • Armywife on A touch of luxury:
    I never go camping without my usual bedding and coffee machine!! No sleeping bags or instant coffee for me!
  • Liz Milner on A touch of luxury:
    Oh My Gosh - this bag is beautiful!
  • Lizzie on A touch of luxury:
    I always remember meeting a woman who had a small yet perfect selection of herbs in little terracotta pots outside her tent. Chives, basil a  

Blogs

Good pages

Good Shopping Handbook