Good—simple choices for a better life

Article illustration

Trans fatty acids

Home » Magazine » Good, issue 9 » Trans fatty acids

Partially hydrogenated vegetable oil doesn’t sound so yummy—and it becomes even less appetising once you learn about the trans fatty acids it contains

What are they?

Trans fatty acids, also known as trans fats, are formed when liquid vegetable oils are converted into semi-solid fats by adding hydrogen. The resulting ‘partially hydrogenated vegetable oil’ is used in commercial food production to make products such as crackers, biscuits, snack foods and baked goods, for deep-frying and to make margarine.

Low levels of trans fatty acids also occur naturally in meat and milk. Animal fats were once the only source of trans fats, but today most trans fat is consumed as partially hydrogenated vegetable oil, which contains up to 45 percent trans fat (of total fat content). Butter contains up to five percent trans fat.

Why are they used?

Partially hydrogenated vegetable oils are used in most commercially baked goods because they are cheaper than animal fats, have a longer shelf life and decrease refrigeration requirements. Partially hydrogenated fat is also popular commercially because of its ‘mouth feel’: it melts in the mouth. Because the fat is semi-solid, it keeps refrigerated margarine spreadable, unlike butter. It’s also vegetarian, vegan, kosher and halal.

What’s the problem?

Trans fat behaves like saturated fat in the body, although the US National Academy of Sciences says trans fatty acids are even more damaging to the heart.

Trans fats raise low-density lipoprotein (LDL, or ‘bad’ cholesterol), which increases your risk of coronary heart disease, heart attack and stroke. They also lower high-density lipoprotein (HDL, or ‘good’ cholesterol), which protects against cardiovascular disease. Trans fatty acids can also cause inflammation in the arteries, increasing the risk of diabetes, and have negative effects on foetal brain development.

Consuming trans fatty acids has no known benefit to human health.

How much am I eating?

Manufacturers aren’t required to label the trans fatty acid content of foods in New Zealand, unless they make a nutrition claim about cholesterol, saturated, polyunsaturated, monounsaturated or trans fatty acids, omega-3, omega-6 or omega-9 fatty acids.

The good news is that consumption of trans fatty acids is quite low in New Zealand, compared with many other countries. We get 0.7 percent of our daily kilojoules from trans fats, according to Food Standards Australia New Zealand (FSANZ), which is below the World Health Organization’s advice to consume no more than 1 percent of daily kilojoules from trans fats.

Health authorities worldwide recommend that people consume only trace amounts of trans fat.

What are the alternatives?

Food manufacturers are increasingly using palm oil as an alternative to partially hydrogenated fats—but since Malaysian and Indonesian rainforests are being cut down to produce palm oil, that’s not a great solution.

The other problem with reducing trans fatty acids in manufactured food is that it often leads to an increase in saturated fat content, which isn’t a healthy result. Butter contains less trans fat than margarine, but usually much more saturated fat and cholesterol. Soft margarines, which have less combined saturated and trans fats, may be a better option for those with cholesterol or heart-health concerns.

The easiest way to avoid trans fats is to avoid manufactured food that contains partially hydrogenated vegetable oil. At home, choose monounsaturated fats such as canola, rice bran and avocado oils (to cook with at high temperatures) and olive and hempseed oils (to use at lower temperatures and in dressings).

Comments

Louise Blackmore
via letters@good.net.nz
 
Thu November 26, 2009 @ 01:49 PM
In “Trans fatty acids” you state that butter contains up to five percent trans fats, with out clarifying the following: “The trans fatty acids found in ruminate fats differ considerably from those found in partially hydrogenated vegetable oils because the average placement of the trans double bond. The major trans fatty acids in ruminant fats have the double bond in the delta-11 position. This … has been given the name of trans-vaccenic acid and it is a precursor to conjugated linoleic acid (CLA), which is reported to be anti-carcinogenic (Chin et al 1992)." This information is from Know Your Fats: the Complete Primer for Understanding the Nutrition of Fats, Oils and Cholesterol by Mary Enig.

I get very frustrated when only half the information is given to the public. I know most people are not as interested as I am in books and papers written on specific ingredients like fats and sugars, and rely on abbreviated reports in the mass media. In my view this is how so much misinformation becomes truth, for example the demonisation of natural animal fats.
Humans survived for millennia on what was supplied by nature. Our health is now degenerating at an accelerated rate. If you follow the chain back, it seems to take a bad turn when man refined sugar; the next downturn was more recent, when natural fats were replaced with processed oils and fats.

The old adage "if it ain't broke don't fix it" applies. It would be very hard to overconsume sugar in an unrefined cane state (which also has minerals that are removed when processed) and fats in their natural state have always sustained us—if they had not we would not be here. Once processed, refined and mucked around with, food is no longer healthful.
Donna Kerridge
via letters@good.net.nz
 
Thu November 26, 2009 @ 01:50 PM
I am a great fan of butter rather than margarine (although I understand neither is an ideal food for someone like me who is overweight and has a moderate risk of developing heart disease). However I prefer butter for a number of reasons I won’t bore you with. The butter verses margarine debate is one that is quite confusing to many of us not sufficiently informed on the science of food production and the intricate workings of our bodies. On the surface, many of the arguments for and against appear conflicting but I guess that in many cases that the facts are often presented with an agenda (either for or against) rather than untruths. And some instances they are genuine errors or make unintentional inferences.

However your article states that butter contains less trans fat than margarine. I imagine this is likely to be true for margarines used in commercial food production but my experience at my local supermarket is that of the total of 23 table margarines (or margarine-like products) on sale all contained a quarter of the amount of trans fats than all four types of butter did. I imagine when your readers read your article many may assume you are talking about table margarine when you state that butter contains less trans fat than margarine. Perhaps something that needs clarification.
I note that butter manufacturers no longer (since June this year) list trans fat content on their butter packaging. Perhaps that’s because our margarine manufacturers have reduced trans fats in table margarines to levels significantly lower than butter.

Without wanting to re-ignite the butter vs margarine debate I believe there are cases where butter will be a better option for people depending on their health status and their ability to show restraint (something I am working on) but there will also be cases when margarine may be a better option for someone else. The big thing is we all need to sure we understand the facts so we can make an informed choice for ourselves.

Clarification about whether your article refers to commercial grade margarines or table margarines and whether or not the statement is true for both grades may help demystify some of the apparent conflict of information around and more importantly help demonstrate to readers the importance of making sure we understand the context of the facts presented to us when making all-important health choices and decisions.
Annabel McAleer
 
Thu November 26, 2009 @ 01:59 PM
Hi Donna,

Well, we have reignited the butter vs marge debate in the Dec/Jan issue, out on Monday! But to clarify the article above, it's partially hydrogenated vegetable oil that has very high levels of trans fats compared to butter, not margarine. Partially hydrogenated vegetable oil is used as an ingredient in lots of things, including some margarines, but mostly it's used in processsed baked products like biscuits.

Hope that clears it up a bit!
Annabel

Add your comment

Anonymous comments are queued before publishing and it may take some time before they appear. Please consider creating an account and your comment will appear automatically. If you already have an account, please log in.








If you have trouble reading the code, click on the code itself to generate a new random code
 

More Goodness

The Good blog
  • Winter pick-me-ups
    article illustration

    As gloomy weather sets in, it's the little things that lift your mood. Like these candy-coloured retro leather purses from Green With Envy – a splash of gorgeousness on the daily shop. And we've got two to give away!

  • How to get rid of oxalis?
    article illustration

    Good's new gardening expert Zoe Carafice is ready and waiting to solve your dilemmas! Each question published on Zoe's blog or in Good receives a fab prize from Tui Garden. This week: how to eradicate oxalis bulbs.

  • One good reason to skip lunch
    article illustration

    Plenty of food that’s good enough to eat (but not good enough to sell) is disposed of every day. Kaibosh Food Rescue is aiming to change all that by collecting extra food and distributing it to charities. Now they're calling on Kiwis to donate the cost of a meal on Miss a Meal in May Day – so they can expand their mission to help out the hungry.

Good magazine
  • Urban harvest
    article illustration

    Could you live off the land? Nancy Howie travels to Canada to discover how one grassroots movement is redefining the suburban dream.

  • Where has fracking been allowed on the East Coast?
    article illustration

    Armed with exploration licenses issued by the New Zealand government, Tag Oil and its partner Apache intend to extract oil and gas from the East Coast. See the map here >

  • Man-made earthquakes
    article illustration

    Is it possible for human activity to cause quakes? One investigation in Blackpool, England discovered that more than fifty tremors in the region were caused by fracking operations. Read the article >

article illustration

Latest issue

Discover what gives your home soul, tips for easy entertaining and making favourite clothes last longer. Find latest research on honey for health and the brainiest breakfasts, plus guides to greenwashing, distilling and the best loo paper to buy.

Follow us

Latest comments

  • Anne on Winter pick-me-ups:
    To survive the cold winter wear wool next to the skin, pile the wood into the woodburner, cook winter soups on top and invite friends in. An  
  • Olivia Winter on Winter pick-me-ups:
    We live in a tiny old house that gets very cold! We lounge around in front of the fireplace in our onesies and our yearly bought novelty sli  
  • Olivia Winter on Spice up your breakfast:
    When I was a child I used to go to my grandparents claybrick house on Waiheke and the first morning I was there nana would bring me breakfas  
  • Vicki Olsen on Winter pick-me-ups:
    Wear lightweight but warm layers of merino clothing, and eat lots of warming soups and crockpot meals.  Get outside on sunny days to bo  
  • Pam Harrison on Winter pick-me-ups:
    Comfort food.  Home made winter soups are the best. Also the humble roast with lots of veggies, gravy and cheese sauce. I als  
  • Kama Scarf on Winter pick-me-ups:
    Open the doors and windows when the sun is shinning during winter to let some fresh air through the house.  Yummy scented candles also  
  • ck smith on Winter pick-me-ups:
    Love those Phoebe purse's, wonderful bright coloursMy best winter-proofing tip is never leave the house without a scarf, hat and gloves  
  • Fi Bennett on Winter pick-me-ups:
    Gorgeous purses - really soft looking and fantastic colours!My husband is a digger operator and will often have to remove old trees to clear  

Blogs

Good pages

Good Shopping Handbook